| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Dec 3 2023 | Chicago at Minnesota (Minnesota -270) | WINNER |
| Dec 3 2023 | Colorado at Los Angeles (Los Angeles -122) | WINNER |
| Dec 3 2023 | Columbus at Boston (Boston -298) | WINNER |
| Dec 3 2023 | Nashville at Buffalo (Buffalo -125) | loss |
| Dec 3 2023 | San Jose at NY Rangers (NY Rangers -470) | WINNER |
| Dec 2 2023 | Boston at Toronto (Toronto -105) | loss |
| Dec 2 2023 | Buffalo at Carolina (Buffalo +195) | loss |
| Dec 2 2023 | Chicago at Winnipeg (Winnipeg -290) | WINNER |
| Dec 2 2023 | Colorado at Anaheim (Colorado -230) | loss |
| Dec 2 2023 | Detroit at Montreal (Detroit -155) | WINNER |
| Dec 2 2023 | NY Islanders at Florida (Florida -185) | loss |
| Dec 2 2023 | NY Rangers at Nashville (NY Rangers -142) | WINNER |
| Dec 2 2023 | Philadelphia at Pittsburgh (Pittsburgh -170) | loss |
| Dec 2 2023 | Seattle at Ottawa (Seattle -102) | loss |
| Dec 2 2023 | St Louis at Arizona (St Louis +105) | loss |
|