| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Dec 18 2025 | Chicago at Montreal (Montreal -173) | WINNER |
| Dec 18 2025 | Dallas at San Jose (Dallas -177) | WINNER |
| Dec 18 2025 | Edmonton at Boston (Edmonton -135) | WINNER |
| Dec 18 2025 | Los Angeles at Tampa Bay (Los Angeles +160) | WINNER |
| Dec 18 2025 | Minnesota at Columbus (Minnesota -104) | WINNER |
| Dec 18 2025 | NY Rangers at St Louis (NY Rangers -137) | WINNER |
| Dec 18 2025 | Philadelphia at Buffalo (Philadelphia +111) | loss |
| Dec 18 2025 | Pittsburgh at Ottawa (Ottawa -173) | WINNER |
| Dec 18 2025 | Seattle at Calgary (Seattle +134) | loss |
| Dec 18 2025 | Toronto at Washington (Washington -145) | WINNER |
| Dec 17 2025 | Carolina at Nashville (Nashville +146) | loss |
| Dec 17 2025 | Los Angeles at Florida (Florida -175) | WINNER |
| Dec 17 2025 | New Jersey at Vegas (Vegas -155) | loss |
| Dec 17 2025 | Utah at Detroit (Detroit -128) | loss |
| Dec 17 2025 | Winnipeg at St Louis (St Louis +119) | WINNER |
|